Back to Search
1 / 25
25 photos
+20
17326 Jamaica Lane
Sugarloaf Key, FL, 33042
Active Under Contract$845,000
17326 Jamaica Lane
Sugarloaf Key, FL, 33042
Active Under Contract$845,000
2
Bedrooms
2
Bathrooms
1,520 sqft
Living Area
1987
Year Built
8,000
Lot Size (sqft)
115
Days on Market
Dock Score™
DockOnly63
GoodWhat shaped this score
✓Ocean Access
✓Dock present
✓Bridge-free to bay
✓Fits boats up to ~40ft (est.)
DockOnly.com rating, not provided by the MLS or listing broker.
Dock & Water AccessMLS
Canal Front
AI Aerial Imagery Detection
Dock DetectedSeawall Detected~20-26 ft dock
Detected by AI from open-source aerial mapping imagery and may not reflect current conditions. This information was not provided by the MLS or listing broker. Always verify dock infrastructure with the listing agent.
Navigation RouteDockOnly
Data sources: SFWMD AHED waterway polygons · FHWA National Bridge Inventory 2024 · Not provided by the MLS or listing broker.
Description
Welcome to your slice of Lower Keys paradise--just 17 miles from Key West yet worlds away from the hustle. This elevated 2-bedroom, 2-bath home sits on a generous lot in a fantastic neighborhood, offering the perfect blend of comfort, style, and island living. Inside, vaulted ceilings and impact windows fill the home with natural light and breezy tropical charm. An elevator makes access effortless, and a whole-home generator keeps life running smoothly no matter the weather. Enjoy the peace of mind of the newer AC! Downstairs, you'll find an expansive storage area ideal for a workshop, gear room, or the ultimate hobby space--plenty of room for tools, toys, and all the essentials of Keys life. Step outside and access the convenience clean canal water surrounded by lush, vibrant landscaping that feels like your own private botanical garden. Enjoy gorgeous views of the natural protected preserve right across the canal allowing for phenomenal sunsets. The all-weather decking is made for morning coffee, sunset cocktails, and everything in between. Boaters and water lovers will appreciate the dedicated skiff launch, making it easy to slip out for a day on the water whenever the mood strikes. Boaters will love being less than a 10-minute ride to open water, making sunset cruises, reef fishing, and sandbar days incredibly easy. Enjoy a scenic ride under the historic Jumping Bridge as you head out -- a true local favorite and iconic Keys experience. Whether you're looking for a full-time residence, weekend escape, or investment opportunity, this home delivers the lifestyle buyers come to the Florida Keys for: sunshine, salt air, and quick access to the water. Relax under the palms, tinker in your workshop, or head out for a quick trip to Key West or Marathon, this home delivers the laid-back tropical lifestyle people dream about. It's island living--comfortable, convenient, and full of character. Your Sugarloaf slice of paradise awaits.
Schedule a Showing
See the property and tour the dock. A licensed waterfront specialist will arrange your private showing.
Select a date
Location
Sugarloaf Key, FL, 33042
No price history available for this property.
Displayed by Blue Mar Real Estate Group Inc., Licensed Florida Real Estate Broker (DBPR CQ1018554) · [email protected]
Listing courtesy of Keller Williams Key West Compass Realty via Florida Keys MLS
Last checked: yesterday
Listing updated: July 30, 2026
© 2026 Florida Keys Board of REALTORS®, Inc. All rights reserved. The data relating to real estate for sale on this website comes in part from the Internet Data Exchange (IDX) program of the Florida Keys Board of REALTORS®. Information is deemed reliable but not guaranteed and should be independently verified. All properties are subject to prior sale, change, or withdrawal.
IDX information is provided exclusively for consumers' personal, non-commercial use. It may not be used for any purpose other than to identify prospective properties consumers may be interested in purchasing.
Dock Score™
DockOnly63
GoodWhat shaped this score
✓Ocean Access
✓Dock present
✓Bridge-free to bay
✓Fits boats up to ~40ft (est.)
DockOnly.com rating, not provided by the MLS or listing broker.
Nearest Bridge Clearances
Florida Keys, critical for tall/large vessels
No bridge data available for this location.
Loading nearby marinas…
Loading nearby sandbars…
Mortgage Calculator
Estimate your monthly payment for this waterfront property
20%
$169,000 down
%
Principal & Interest$4,385/mo
Property Tax (est. ~1.2%, varies by county)$845/mo
Home Insurance (est.)$250/mo
Total Monthly Payment$5,480
Loan Amount: $676,000Rate: 6.75%
Get Pre-QualifiedEstimated payments only. Actual rates and terms may vary.
Similar Listings
$999,00095 Coco Plum Unit Drive 4B
Marathon, FL
3 3 1,769 sqft
Courtesy of Ocean Sotheby's International via Florida Keys MLS
$660,00074 Pelican Ln
Big Pine, FL
3 3 1,152 sqft
Courtesy of My Realty Group, LLC. via MIAMI REALTORS®
$1,050,0001331 Hudgins Drive
Summerland Key, FL
2 2 1,023 sqft
Courtesy of Home Sold Realty, LLC via Florida Keys MLS
$964,99930368 Killdeer Ln
Big Pine, FL
3 2 1,200 sqft
Courtesy of Pine River Realty, LLC via Florida Keys MLS
$999,00024225 W Caribbean Drive
Summerland Key, FL
3 2 1,056 sqft
Courtesy of Coldwell Banker Schmitt RE Co. via Florida Keys MLS
$847,90034 7th Street
Key Colony Beach, FL
2 2 868 sqft
Courtesy of LoKation via MIAMI REALTORS®
Swipe or use arrows to see more
Navigation note: Navigation routes show the shortest mapped path to open water. A vessel taller than the binding bridge clearance may still reach open water via a longer alternate route that we don't currently map. Verify navigability with a local captain or surveyor before relying on it.